Editor’s Letter, Winter 2015

from Gastronomica 15:4


Retro food stands invoking 1950s and 1960s Moscow offer hot corn on the cob, drinks, and ice cream to passersby enjoying Moscow’s City Day along Tverskaya ulitsa.

I am writing this letter from Moscow, where I am spending a few days visiting friends. I was eager to return after a year away, not simply to catch up with loved ones but also to find out what was happening with Russia’s food scene following the bans on foreign food products that were instituted last summer and the recent reports about fake foods and the destruction of contraband food imports.

I arrived on the eve of Moscow’s City Day celebrations, and discovered that the anniversary themes focused on the city’s history as told through cultural, artistic, and technological innovations. For a city celebrating its 868th year, that is a lot of history and innovations, and much of that lengthy span was held together by placing a special emphasis on food in Russia’s capital city: the “Capital City Gastronomic Festival.” Neighborhoods all around Moscow were organized around subthemes that evoke the historical contexts of those particular regions: “National Supper” in the region closest to the federal and city government buildings; “Soviet Dinner” just outside Red Square and the Kremlin; “Farmers’ Dinner” in a square that was once a farmers’ market; “Theater Buffet” in one of the oldest neighborhoods with numerous theaters and the celebrated theater university; and “Literary Dinner” in the square ringed by the major newspaper and book publishing houses. At the center of each designated neighborhood was a cluster of food stalls, each decorated to look like peasant cottages and promoting regional food specialties, stages for musical performances, and organized activities reflecting the neighborhood’s assigned subthemes. In the “Literary Dinner” neighborhood, for instance, visitors sampled local food treats while receiving free issues and other goodies from the many Moscow-based newspapers and publishers. The focus was on both Eating Locally and Reading Locally. Along Tverskaya Ulitsa, the main boulevard that leads to Red Square and the Kremlin, visitors walked through the centuries of Moscow’s past and not only saw but had the opportunity to taste foods from “the past”—including cafeteria-style foods sold from a Soviet-era stolovaya (cafeteria).

Moscow’s focus on food, and on local food, whether rendered as regional, historic, or national, is apparent elsewhere in the city, most notably in an explicit aesthetic of nostalgia. Ice cream carts and beverage vending machines from the 1950s and 1960s have taken up residence in food courts and along busy city streets. Food shop clerks are dressed in the blue-and-white aprons and hats that were more common during the socialist and early postsocialist eras in state-run stores. And noticeable among the Russian food products on store shelves is a return to Soviet-era packaging styles.

What are we to make of this? On the one hand, this effort can be seen as a glorification of food patriotism and food nationalism, a topic that is near and dear to my heart and that I have discussed before. On the other hand, it is important to remember that what seems to be very political can also be quite personal. It is equally possible that these food events are as much about familiarity and comfort, or even irony, as they are about making an international political statement. Foods contain and convey messages at multiple levels and to multiple audiences, and those messages may change according to the historical and cultural context or even with regard to how a particular audience receives and decodes them. For me, this is one of the most fascinating aspects of food studies: food makes us think and makes us question. Food is knowledge, and knowledge can be food. As one of Moscow’s bookstores put it in an advertisement in their window this week: “Books are pizza for the brain.” Perhaps by extension, pizza—or any other food—can be a book for the stomach.


Moscow residents celebrate Moscow’s City Day at the “Literary Dinner” square located at Tverskaya metro station, right in the center of the central media and publishing house district.


A 1950s/1960s–themed beverage cart offering flavored waters sits nestled alongside a hot food stand offering fajitas (fakhitas) and American-style barbeque.

It is this power of food to provoke, to inspire, to communicate, and to satiate that runs through the contributions to this issue of Gastronomica. These are, in many ways, eclectic pieces that touch on very diverse topics. As editor, I hope that every issue’s contributions are meaty and stimulating, but there is something about this particular issue and the diversity of topics and viewpoints that I have found especially thought-provoking. In various ways, each of the contributions has raised critical issues and questions that have challenged me to think differently. It is truly a literary feast.


Hungry Moscow residents grab a quick bite to eat in a Soviet-style cafeteria. Traditional cafeterias like these have quietly disappeared in Moscow as they have been replaced by sit-down restaurants and cafés.

The first piece is, naturally enough, pizza-related. Zachary Nowak presents a lively and detailed interview with Antonio Mattozzi about his recent book, Inventing the Pizzeria. Their conversation is not so much about a book as it is a history of a family and a culinary tradition that invites us to reconsider what we believe we know about pizza and family businesses. This interview is followed by a series of research briefs that raise new questions and offer new directions of research for food. Chika Watanabe’s essay on waste and philosophies of circulation forces us to think seriously about what a truly sustainable system of local agriculture might look like and whether consumers would be comfortable with their personal roles in sustainability initiatives. Watanabe also opens up possibilities for rethinking terroir and taste of place: when we take waste seriously, can we also talk about a “taste of person”? Anna Harris continues this thread of productive discomfort by suggesting that there are sensory deficits in approaching food through taste, smell, touch, and vision; and she asks what happens if we consider the sounds of food and food work. While sound has been important for food manufacturers in terms of how they design products, it has so far evaded critical inquiry among scholars and even ordinary consumers. Harris provides an entry point for thinking about a fuller sensory spectrum and the implications of paying attention to the sounds our food makes.

In their essays, Levi Van Sant and Ernesto Hernández-López tackle the political dimensions of the sensory qualities of food. For Hernández-López, it is about the legal, social, and cultural implications of the problems faced by the California-based company that makes Sriracha, the popular hot sauce, when local residents complained about the fumes believed to emanate from the factory, and by extension presented a political critique of the people associated with those sensory experiences. Van Sant takes on an equally charged topic by considering the racial politics contained within a culinary tradition constructed as part of a unique heritage culture: that of Lowcountry cuisine in South Carolina. By looking at constructions of heritage, taste, race, and class across popular cookbooks, Van Sant critically examines how tastes are deeply embedded in experiences of race and class. What makes this piece especially powerful is that the setting at the heart of Van Sant’s essay is Charleston, the site of recent horrific events that have laid bare some of the very issues that Van Sant explores.

The research essays continue this emphasis on provoking challenging and even difficult conversations. In the first research essay, Kimberly Nettles-Barcelón curates a conversation among a group of women chefs and food researchers about the experience and value of food work by Black women. From different perspectives and vantage points—some as scholars and some as professional chefs—the contributors to this conversation discuss important issues about how labor, expertise, authority, and voice in the food world are directly shaped by political systems of race and gender. This is an inspiring essay that nonetheless reminds us of the pervasive inequalities that continue to shape professional food work both inside and outside the academy.

In her essay, Tracy Bilsing brings a different perspective on gender and politics by introducing previously little-known work by Katherine Mansfield in which she reflects on the Great War. Bilsing not only provides a critical historical service by uncovering Mansfield’s less familiar work, but she also challenges us to reconsider the relationship between food and war and how these relationships are presented in different literary mediums.

Resituating history and heritage is also central to Gina Hunter’s essay on galeterias in Brazil. By discussing the resurgence of Italian-Brazilian culinary heritage as both a contemporary reworking of Italian immigration to Brazil and an outgrowth of culinary tourism, Hunter opens up new directions for thinking about how ethnic identities and histories are mobilized at different moments and for different cultural and economic purposes.


Moscow pedestrians enjoy the “Capital Breakfast” themed square, decorated with carts filled with pumpkins for autumn.

Emma McDonell asks the provocative question of how certain foods become “miracle foods”—or those foods that are valorized for their potential to save a community, a heritage, a society. In this case, McDonell considers how particular foods have, at different moments, been promoted through global development initiatives to prevent hunger or malnutrition but have ultimately failed. She focuses specifically on the development politics of quinoa and the tensions that play out between global development actors (both scientists and politicians) and local farmers and consumers.

Lastly, the creative reflections in this issue engage thoughtfully with questions and issues raised in the essays by turning more personal and contemplative, but in ways that are more attuned to the bodily and the sensory. Fa-Tai Shieh muses on how and what we think about the foods that we put into our mouths and bodies. Taking this question about ingestion further, Kiran Bhushi describes the experience of spending time at an Ayurveda Hospital in India and a personal realignment with the sensory attributes of food. Daniel Press takes issue with the perceptions implicit and explicit in the wine industry and shows how the power of suggestion and presentation directly influence sensory experiences and evaluations.

I invite you to come join me in this movable feast by journeying through time, space, and multiple sensory registers.

Melissa L. Caldwell
September 2015

Fall 2015, Volume 15, Number 3

Fall 2015, Volume 15, Number 3

FROM THE EDITOR
Editor’s Letter | Melissa L. Caldwell

SOAS FOOD STUDIES CENTRE DISTINGUISHED LECTURE
An Interview with James C. Scott | Harry G. West and Celia Plender

RESEARCH BRIEF
Milking It: The Pastoral Imaginary of California’s (Non)Dairy Farming | Kyle Bladow

RESEARCH ESSAYS
Making Sense of Urban Gardens | Cindy Ott

Thinking Critically about Academic–Industry Collaborations

Commercial Collaboration and Critical Engagement in Food Research | Peter Jackson

Researching (with) Major Food Retailers: Leveling and Leveraging the Terms of Engagement | David Evans

Engaging Science with Commercial Partners: The (Dating) Stages of a (Lasting) Relationship | Monica Truninger

The Power-geometry of Food Business Research | Peter Jackson

Archives, Academy, and Access: Food Producer Life Stories | Polly Russell

In Response

Embracing the Elephant | Charlotte Biltekoff

Industry Expert Reflections | Louise Bland

The Knowledge Economy in Corporate Engagement | Katherine Smith

Food Corporations and Collaborative Research | James L. Watson

CREATIVE REFLECTIONS
Affogato | Dorian Fox

French Soup Alchemy | Ali Shakir

Brscht – A Love Story | Bryan Demchinsky

Eat These Words | J. H. Pearl

REVIEW ESSAY
Breakfast, Brunch, and Leisure | Charles Reeve

REVIEWS
Typicality in History: Tradition, Innovation, and Terroir Edited by Giovanni Ceccarelli, Alberto Grandi, and Stefano Magagnoli, Reviewed by Rengenier C. Rittersma

Beyond Alternative Food Networks: Italy’s Solidarity Purchase Groups By Cristina Grasseni, Reviewed by Jillian R. Cavanaugh

A Farm Dies Once a Year By Arlo Crawford, Reviewed by Katy Overstreet

Fish and Chips: A History By Panikos Panayi, Reviewed by Peter Scholliers

The Third Plate: Field Notes on the Future of Food By Dan Barber, Reviewed by Christian Man

The Insect Cookbook: Food for a Sustainable Planet By Arnold van Huis, Henk van Gurp, and Marcel Dicke, Reviewed by Jonas House

Alternative Food Networks: Knowledge, Practice, and Politics By David Goodman, E. Melanie DuPuis, and Michael K. Goodman, Reviewed by Chhaya Kolavalli

BOOKS RECEIVED

 

Top Images:

FIGURE 3: HopeBUILD garden manager Ryan, second from right, works with volunteers in a community garden sponsored by Union. Memorial United Methodist Church in north St. Louis in 2009. The church took over garden management four years later. Courtesy of hopebuild. jonathan gayman © 2009

FIGURE 4: A selection from the 2009 harvest of the Union Memorial. United Methodist Church garden. Courtesy of hopebuild. jonathan gayman © 2009

Flavors of Ireland | Darra Goldstein

from Gastronomica 12:3

When our daughter was little, she loved hearing legends of the selkie girls, mermaid-like creatures who inhabit the waters off the Irish coast. Sleek as seals in the sea, they shed their skin once captured and turn into humans on land, yet they always long to return to the deep. Leila is grown now, and I haven’t thought about selkies for years, but they came vividly to mind a couple of months ago when I visited the southwest coast of Ireland, where I spent a magical day on the water foraging for seaweed by kayak. Gannets and gulls swooped through the air, on the lookout for fish. As we paddled through a natural arch I caught sight of a grey seal poised on a rock. A selkie! In that misty environment all transformations seemed possible.

I had flown to Ireland to speak at the first Dublin Gastronomy Symposium, brilliantly organized by Máirtín Mac ConIomaire at the Dublin Institute of Technology. Afterwards I headed to West Cork to meet John and Sally McKenna, creators of the annual Bridgestone Irish Food Guide. For a couple of years Sally has teamed up with Jim Kennedy at Atlantic Sea Kayaking to offer special foraging trips. Jim, an international champion kayaker who traded racing for gentler paddling, guided us along the rocky coast to a trove of seaweed in vivid colors: yellow and orange and purple and pink. We found carrageen and dilisk and sea lettuce and kelp—all common along the Irish coast—and were thrilled to spot a far rarer bloom of nori. I took a bite: mineral and salt, tasting of rock and sea. I nibbled on a couple of different kinds of wrack and sloke that were mainly chewy, but I swooned over pepper dulse with its piquant bite. As we hovered by the rocks, the clouds shifted, turning the water and sky various shades of grey and blue. Changeability defines this landscape—no wonder selkie legends arose. And no wonder that the dull brown strands of sea spaghetti drifting in the water should turn emerald green on boiling. Surely the tresses of mermaids!

Photograph by Jim Kennedy © 2012

Read more

Summer 2012, Volume 12, Number 2

Summer 2012, Volume 12, Number 2

from the editor
How the Other Half Eats | Darra Goldstein

borborygmus
Rumblings from the World of Food

orts and scantlings
The Girl with the Cupcake Tattoo | Mark Morton

poem
Partial Recipe for Brunswick Stew | Andrea Cohen

feast for the eye
Suzanne Lacy: Chewing More Than the Fat | Cameron Shaw

poem
Double Boiler | Lilah Hegnauer

slow food
Farming the Monsoon: A Return to Traditional Tohono O’odham Foods | Marcello Di Cintio

photographs
At Home in Kyrgyzstan | Lynn Alleva Lilley

eating out
Table for One | Matt Goulding

origins
A Man Walks into a Pub | Ian Klaus

investigations
Women, Sabotaj, and Underground Food Economies in Haiti | Myron M. Beasley
Charles Darwin, the Gourmet Traveler | Diana Noyce

family history
Kimchi Blues | Grace M. Cho

religion
Of Raspberries and Religion | Susan H. Swetnam

americana
Men Who Eat Muskrat: It’s Nothing Like Chicken | William Woys Weaver

terroir
The Big Apple Exchange | Alexandra Leaf; photographs by Joel Seaman

marketing
American Processed Kosher | Jeffrey Yoskowitz

memoir
The One-Second Sandwich | Toni Mirosevich

festivals
Vendimia Celebrations | Paula de la Cruz

shopping
Sahadi’s: A Family Affair | Jason Leahey

ecology
Hogonomics | Barry Estabrook

chef’s page
An Interview with Daniel Humm, Eleven Madison Park | Anne E. McBride

review essays
Red in Spine and Claw | Patricia Gadsby
Gastronomy or Gluttony? | Priscilla Parkhurst Ferguson

the bookshelf
Books in Review

lagniappe
The Mutato Project | Uli Westphal

Cover: Antonio López García, La cena (The Dinner), 1971–1980 (detail). © 2011 Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / VEGAP, Madrid.

Winter 2010, Volume 10, Number 1

Winter 2010, Volume 10, Number 1

from the editor
Feast in a Time of Famine | Darra Goldstein

borborygmus
Rumblings from the World of Food

cartoons
Something Tastes Funny: Toasting Ten Years of Gastronomica | David Sipress

orts and scantlings
“Gastrobamica” | Mark Morton

feast for the eye
An Apt and Noble Gift: Gorham’s Rebekah Pitcher | Amy Miller Dehan

poem
On Curing Images and Pork | Tung-Hui Hu

memoir
Eating White | Geoff Nicholson

gender
Why Are There No Great Women Chefs? | Charlotte Druckman

rituals
Rites of Passage in Italy | Carol Field

forum
Food Porn | Anne E. McBride

slice of life
Sweet Tooth Nation: Fabrico Próprio and the Portuguese Pastry | Frances Baca

fashion
“Another Form of Her Genius”: Lee Miller in the Kitchen | Becky E. Conekin

investigations
Jean-Baptiste Labat and the Buccaneer Barbecue in Seventeenth-Century Martinique | Suzanne Toczyski
Conviviality in Catalonia | A.F. Robertson

archive
Lucent Figs and Suave Veal Chops: Sylvia Plath and Food | Lynda K. Bundtzen

consumption
Like Your Labels? | Michele Field

americana
Moxie: A Flavor for the Few | Robert Dickinson

identity
Culinary Nationalism | Priscilla Parkhurst Ferguson
Silver Lining: Building a Shared Sudanese Identity through Food | A.V. Crofts

futurism
Losing the Space Race | Kay Sexton

photographs
The Color of Hay: The Peasants of Maramures | Kathleen Laraia McLaughlin and H. Woods McLaughlin

prose
A Pinch of Finch | Toni Mirosevich

terroir
Discovering Terroir in the World of Chocolate | Bill Nesto

design
Guinomi | Allen S. Weiss

chef’s page
Executive Pastry Chef, Washington, D.C. | Bill Yosses

review essays
Aesthetics and Alchemy in the Contemporary Kitchen | Joanne Molina
Food Enigmas, Colonial and Postcolonial | Sidney W. Mintz

the bookshelf
Books in Review

lagniappe
Collard Leaves for Misery | Ardath Weaver

Cover: Farhad Moshiri, Blood Fountain, 2006, oil on canvas. Courtesy of Daneyal Mahmood Gallery, New York.